Skip to content

Buying guide

Best charcoal smokers for low and slow

Chosen from what the Amazon listings state, not tested by us. How we pick

Note: This page contains affiliate links. If you buy through them we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more

Top picks at a glance

Compare them all
  • Best overall

    Weber Smokey Mountain 14.5 in: compact bullet smoker

    A tall, narrow 37 x 37 cm footprint fits a corner of a small patio.

  • Best value

    Royal Gourmet CC1830W: 811 sq in with offset box

    811 sq in in total across the main grates, warming rack and offset box.

  • Most features

    Oklahoma Joe's Laredo 1100: 1,100 sq in offset

    The 1,100 sq in total cooking space is the largest of the smokers in this guide.

Low and slow cooking means holding a steady 110 to 135 °C for hours, often through a cool, breezy British evening. Charcoal smokers do this in three main ways. A bullet smoker stacks the fire, a water pan and two grates in a tall cylinder, which is compact and holds temperature well. An offset smoker burns the fire in a side box and draws smoke across a long chamber, which gives plenty of space for ribs and brisket but needs more tending. A kettle with a hinged grate, char ring and diffuser plate can smoke well too, and grills on other nights. What separates a good smoker is air control, a tight lid, enough grate area for your usual cook and easy access to add fuel. This guide compares six charcoal smokers and smoking-ready grills by those points, from the listings only.

All products compared

The products in detail

No. 1 · Weber

Weber Smokey Mountain 14.5 in: compact bullet smoker

Weber's smallest Smokey Mountain Cooker, a bullet smoker with two 13.5 in grids for 286 sq in in total and a cover. It suits a small garden and cooks for a family on long, steady smokes.

In its favour

  • A tall, narrow 37 x 37 cm footprint fits a corner of a small patio.
  • Two grids give 286 sq in in total for ribs on one level and a chicken on the other.
  • A cover is included in the box, which helps through damp UK winters.

Good to know

  • The 14.5 in size is too small for a whole brisket or several racks of ribs at once.
  • The listing gives little detail on vents, water pan or fuel door.
Check price on AmazonAffiliate link

Listing title: Weber 14.5 -inch Smokey Mountain Cooker, Charcoal Smoker,Black

No. 2 · Oklahoma Joe's

Oklahoma Joe's Laredo 1100: 1,100 sq in offset

A large offset smoker with 1,100 sq in of total cooking space, a 184 sq in firebox and three porcelain-coated grates. Built for big cooks of ribs, brisket and pork shoulder.

In its favour

  • The 1,100 sq in total cooking space is the largest of the smokers in this guide.
  • The dedicated firebox supports true offset smoking or direct grilling, with an ash pan.
  • Side, front and bottom shelves keep tools, trays and wood within reach.

Good to know

  • At 163.7 cm wide and 43.1 kg it needs a large, level patio.
  • Offset smokers need regular fire tending to hold a steady temperature.
Check price on AmazonAffiliate link

Listing title: Oklahoma Joe’s Laredo Series 1100 Offset Smoker

No. 3 · Weber

Weber Master-Touch GBS Premium: kettle with smoking kit

A 57 cm Master-Touch kettle that comes with a char ring and diffuser plate for grilling, roasting and smoking. One grill that handles weeknight burgers and weekend smokes.

In its favour

  • A char ring and diffuser plate turn the kettle into a smoker without extra purchases.
  • A hinged lid stays attached, so checking the food is a one-handed job.
  • Weber lists 3-in-1 use for grilling, roasting and smoking.

Good to know

  • A kettle holds less meat on a smoke than a bullet stack or offset chamber.
  • The listing is short and does not describe vents or ash handling.
Check price on AmazonAffiliate link

Listing title: WEBER CHARCOAL GRILL MASTER TOUCH GBS PREMIUM E-5775 BLK

No. 4 · Oklahoma Joe's

Oklahoma Joe's Blackjack: kettle with smokestack

A heavy-duty kettle on a cart with a hinged lid, a 382 sq in grate, a side shelf and wagon wheels. Oklahoma Joe's states a two year warranty on all parts.

In its favour

  • A hinged lid stays attached, so there is nowhere awkward to put it down.
  • A 360° air intake and smokestack give control for both high heat and low and slow.
  • The listing states a two year warranty on all parts.

Good to know

  • At 29.5 kg it is much heavier than a standard kettle.
  • The 382 sq in grate is a little smaller than a 57 cm Weber kettle.
Check price on AmazonAffiliate link

Listing title: Oklahoma Joe's® Blackjack Kettle Charcoal Grill - 21302141

No. 5 · Royal Gourmet

Royal Gourmet CC1830W: 811 sq in with offset box

A 30 in barrel grill with an attached offset smoker box, 443 sq in of main grates and wood-painted tables. A lighter way to try offset smoking on a smaller patio.

In its favour

  • 811 sq in in total across the main grates, warming rack and offset box.
  • A two-level adjustable charcoal pan helps control heat in the main chamber.
  • Front and side tables plus S hooks give prep space and tool storage.

Good to know

  • The charcoal pan holds up to 4.4 lb (about 2 kg), so long cooks need refuelling.
  • The listing does not describe the dampers in detail.
Check price on AmazonAffiliate link

Listing title: Royal Gourmet CC1830W 30-Inch Charcoal Grill with Offset Smoker and Wo...

No. 6 · Royal Gourmet

Royal Gourmet 30 in offset: side door for fuel

A 30 in barrel grill with an offset firebox and an easy-open side door for adding charcoal and removing ash. Similar to the CC1830W but with plain tables and a lid thermometer.

In its favour

  • A side door on the firebox makes adding charcoal and clearing ash easy mid-cook.
  • The offset box is firmly attached for good heat and smoke circulation, says the maker.
  • A lid-mounted thermometer gauge shows chamber temperature.

Good to know

  • The charcoal pan holds up to 4.4 lb, so plan to top up on longer smokes.
  • Its layout is almost the same as the CC1830W, so compare the tables and finish.
Check price on AmazonAffiliate link

Listing title: Royal Gourmet BBQ Charcoal Grill and Offset Smoker, 30'' L, 800 Square...

Read before you buy

More buying guides: Smokers and pellet grills

Char and Smoke chooses every product independently, based on what its Amazon listing states. We may earn a commission on purchases made through the affiliate links above. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.